JayToddz for the masses

  • Archive
  • RSS
  • Ask us anything!
  • Submit

I voted for Jason to…

As a part of an ongoing installment, we’ve been looking for people who voted for Jason in DC’s phone-in poll Sept. 15-16, 1988, which determined that Jason would die. Jim Zimmerman, a moderator of the Batman forum for CBR voted for Jason to live, and he graciously offered to answer our questions. He discusses it in more detail here:
1. What do you remember of the advertising for the vote?

Not much. I believe it was announced at the end of the issue and I’m pretty sure that DC told the retailers this was coming in advance. There may have been house ads in some of the other DC titles, but I really can’t remember.

2. Do you remember being influenced to vote in one way or the other? If so, how do you feel you were influenced? 

Not at all.

3. How much did it cost? 

I don’t remember. (Wikipedia says fifty cents)

4. Which way did you vote?

That Jason would live.

5. Why did you vote that way? 
I liked Jason. I didn’t like the revamped version of the character as well as the original, but I still didn’t want him killed.

6. How old were you at the time?

37

7. What do you remember of people talking about it before and afterwards? 

There was a lot of interest in it. I increased my store’s order significantly, but still sold out very quickly. I remember a lot of customers telling me they were voting for him to die. When I asked why, the comment I remember hearing a lot was, “Because Robin is a wimp.” Many of these were not regular Batman readers and I’m not sure they even realized that this wasn’t the original Robin.

8. Were you surprised at the outcome? Why or why not? 

Not really, because of what I related directly above.

What about the reaction of people following his death?

Surprise and increased interest in the book, at least in the short term.

9. Anything else you’d like to add?

Don’t think so.

__________________
Thank you so much, Jim! And just as a reminder, we’re looking for anyone who voted either way in the phone-in poll to contact us! 

    • #I voted for Jason
    • #phone-in poll
    • #vote
    • #death
    • #Robin
    • #phone in vote
  • 1 year ago
  • 4
  • Comments
  • Permalink
Share

Short URL

TwitterFacebookPinterestGoogle+

…years ago, DC did the “Vote on Jason Todd — Live or Die” phone-in event where fans were encouraged to call in and decide if Batman’s newest sidekick lived or died. At the time it felt fun and fresh and exciting. But as my longtime friend Jim Salicrup pointed out to me, when you let the audience decide what happens in the story, you are telling them the story isn’t “real” — because they can change the outcome.

Imagine how much more boring a football game would be if the cheers of the crowd dictated who scored a touchdown, rather than the crowd cheering because the touchdown was scored. That would be a game of who cheered the loudest, not a game based on the skills and luck of the players involved.

Scott Lobdell (via)

Welp, officially IN LOVE WITH SCOTT LOBDELL

    • #Scott Lobdell
    • #interview
    • #interviews
    • #A Death in the Family
    • #phone in vote
  • 1 year ago > theblast
  • 45
  • Comments
  • Permalink
Share

Short URL

TwitterFacebookPinterestGoogle+

Portrait/Logo

About

Jason Peter Todd. The second Robin. The second Red Hood. Died. Came back better than ever.
A blog for all your Jason Todd related news, history, pictures, video, comics, questions and art.

Logo by breakuptheband
The blog is queer positive, women friendly and does post images of 'slash' on occasion.


Posts of Interest:
What are some good Jason centric comics to read?
Jason Todd's activity book of fun!
Robin's Requiem: The tale of Jason Todd
Jason's first appearance
The Heroic Acts of Jason Todd
In Defense of Jason Todd essays
Letters to the editor about Jason
Interviews with writers about Jason
Newspaper articles discussing Jason
That bloody crowbar!
How close was the phone-in vote?
How Jason gained the Robin suit
Who is Scarlet?
Important people in Jason's history and world
Who's to blame? How Jason Todd is blamed for his demise essay part one,
part two Updated here

Transcending Trauma: From Batman to the Red Hood: a Q & A interview with Broadcast Thought
What's the deal with the red hair?
Count Jason's costumes!
Red Hood: The Lost Days sales comparisons
The drunken history of Jason Todd!
What happened when Superboy Prime punched a "reality" wall?
Looking for Jason Todd centric trades?
The similarities and differences between DCAU Tim Drake and Jason Todd
A lot like Robin if you close your eyes: a link to writer Mary Borsellino's dissection of classism in the Batfamily
Jason's death as featured in the 1986 futuristic tale The Dark Knight Returns
That time they mentioned Jason on The Big Bang Theory
When Jason was featured on Batman: The Brave and the Bold"
Wondering if your question has already been answered? Check here!
  • RSS
  • Random
  • Archive
  • Ask us anything!
  • Submit
  • Mobile
Effector Theme by Pixel Union